CSI scene compared to the Phillips Commercial...

At the beginning of the last unit, i made a post on the Phillips commercial which won the cannes - Lion 2009 Grand Prix. When i got home on saturday, my Mum had kept a recorded episode of CSI which attempted a similar effect. For me, it doesn't work anywhere near as well and a lot of it seems fairly flat, but you can definitely tell where the idea came from. Although, it always interests me to see experimental pieces of work like this because i am always interested in fiding out how they composed them and edited the sequences together... Check it out...